With massive mask shortages taking place all around the world currently, many are turning to creative solutions for filtering their air. While these solutions are better than nothing, they are often far from proper filters that are designed for particle filtration.
In times like this, many people, companies and organisations are looking for alternatives that can provide adequate protection from fine particles that are not only easy to produce but also cheap and easy to access.
Re-Mask is soon going to launch another product though, and that is the Earth Filter. This filter is designed to be a solution to the global mask shortages and to provide any mask with higher filtration efficiency.
This article contains affiliate links. For more information, please refer to my affiliate disclaimer.
Earth Filter is currently in Kickstarter, I was sent test samples of the product in order to write a review. All opinions expressed in this post are my own. Please keep in mind that Kickstarters don’t always succeed, and to always do your due diligence before backing a project.
Earth Filter Concept
The idea behind Earth Filter is that there needs to be a universal filter that anyone can use. Whether you have a scarf, surgical mask, or respirator, there should be a single filter that can be placed within these to provide further protection to the wearer.
I think that the Earth Filter Kickstarter provides the best description of the issue: ‘Due to the shortage of surgical masks, a lot of us have bought fabric masks to protect ourselves from the current pandemic. The problems are fabric mask themselves, regardless of if they are cotton or polyester, they do not have the capability to filter small particles. On average, fabric masks can only filter up to 20% of the airborne particles in the air.
In plain words, fabric masks alone are not good enough. A filter is needed to add filtering capability to fabric masks. However, filters come in different sizes and shapes, which means you might need to pair a specific mask to a specific filter.’
In order to try and solve this issue, Earth Filter has been designed to fit inside a large range of masks and to meet high filtering standards. In this review of the Earth Filter, I want to investigate the filtration capabilities of the filter, the fit, and to also look into how it works with some of the other masks that I have.
The Earth Filter has 5 layers including a carbon filter.
Earth Filter has recently been tested by Nelson Labs and has achieved high results. However, it is important to note that a filter can only filter the air that passes through it. That is to say, fit testing is very important for achieving the highest filtration efficacy.
Since Earth Filter is only a filter, and not a mask itself, it is vital to make sure the filter is fitted correctly. While getting a perfect fit is near impossible, the Earth Filter will provide better protection than cloth masks and surgical masks when it is fitted well.
For the best protection, use a mask that has a wire nose-piece or is tight-fitting with minimal leaks. I have found that the Earth Filter works (and fits) well in my MeoAir mask, Re-Mask and also in Gill Mask. While the filter fits many masks, those with a tight fit (that force the air to pass through the filter) will have far better results.
The filter itself has been tested to have ≥ 99.76% filtration at an MPPS of 0.3μm. This result instantly puts the filtration capabilities of the Earth Filter at a similar level to the TotoBobo mask, Cambridge Mask, and many other popular reusable masks.
At the same particle size (MPPS of 0.3μm) the Earth Filter was also found to be ≥ 97.3% effective at filtering bacterial particles and 99.9% effective at filtering viral particles. This means that when the filter is fitted correctly it is capable of filtering the vast majority of particles.
|Filtration %||≥ 99.76%||> 99.9%||≥ 97.3%|
All data used is from the Re-Mask Nelson Lab test results.
It is important to note that particles smaller than 0.3μm will be filtered more effectively. I often get asked how effective masks and respirators are against smaller particles – the answer is that they are very effective. While there are limited studies on nanoparticle filtration, down to 4nm N95 respirators have been found to provide more than 95% filtration (source).
The Earth Mask also features a carbon filter which is a welcome addition. These filters are designed to remove organic compounds by means of adsorption (not absorption!). While these filters aren’t effective against most non-organic compounds, they are useful at filtering pollutants such as benzene, toluene, xylene, oils and more (source).
Another benefit of carbon filters is that they are capable of filtering some odours. This means that when wearing the Earth Filter you should notice less smells – however, this only applies to some chemicals.
While some respirators have carbon filters within, the addition of such a filter still isn’t commonplace. Although this is a welcome addition, it is important to note that if you need protection from chemicals or gases a specialised respirator is essential.
Earth Filter in Masks
I tested the Earth Filter in a variety of different masks to see if the universal fit claim is true. While it won’t fit every mask, I did find that it fits well in a large variety of masks. Frankly, with the differences in mask sizes, I was impressed with how many masks the Earth Filter fit well.
While the filter isn’t intended to be used inside masks that already have a filter, I first tried the Earth Filter within a Cambridge Mask and Vogmask. The filter was too large for both of these masks (they are both small size). I believe the filter would fit well in larger models of Vogmask and Cambridge Mask, however.
I then tried the filter in the MeoAir Mask. This mask has interchangeable filters, and as such, it is a more likely scenario for using an Earth Filter. On my small-sized MeoAir Mask, the filter fits perfectly. Since the mask also has a good fit with a wire nose-piece, I found this to be perhaps the best fitting mask out of everything that I tried.
Of course, the filter also works well in Re-Mask’s masks. Although the Earth Filter is not designed to be used in these masks (they have their own filters), the Earth Filter fits well. On the large models, the filter was slightly too small, but it fits well on the smaller models.
Afterwards, I tried the Aropec Mask. I thought this would be an interesting choice as the Aropec is an antiviral mask, but one that doesn’t have tested particle filtration capabilities. The filter fit well, however, it did move a bit during wear and this is something to be aware of.
The same goes for surgical masks and other cloth masks. If you have a tight-fitting cloth mask, the filter can fit well. However, I found that surgical masks were typically too loose (even when tightened and folded before wearing) for the filter. It tended to move a bit during wear, and it needed to be readjusted.
Finally, I also tested the Earth Filter in some other respirators. The two that I tested were standard KN95 and KF94 variants. Although the filter is not intended to be used in masks that already have capable filters, I found that it fit well and needed little adjustment. The issue is that the breathing resistance was quite significant due to having two filters.
Typically, the Earth Filter should fit any medium to larger sized mask. It may be a struggle getting the Earth Filter to fit in smaller masks (such as S sizes from Cambridge Mask and Vogmask), however, it did fit in the majority of masks that I tested.
Again, it is important to remember that the Earth Filter will not be fully effective unless it is fitted correctly. If you don’t have access to a well-fitting mask, the filter can provide some protection. However, a well-fitting respirator that the Earth Filter fits well will provide the best results.
Earth Filter works well with Re-Mask
The Earth Filter is an innovative idea to reduce waste and to make filters more widely accessible. While the idea of a universal filter may not be new, the Earth Filter is the best fitting filter that I have tested to date.
The filter has been tested and proven to provide high filtering efficiencies. It performs similarly or better than many of the other reusable masks on the market and it is capable of fitting in many masks on the market.
For the best results with the filter, I would recommend using it in a mask that it fits in well. From my experience, the Re-Mask Casual and MeoAir Mask fit the filter best and provide a good overall fit.
If you currently only have access to surgical masks, cloth masks, or other less effective masks, then the Earth Filter is a great way to add some extra filtration capabilities. Not only is adding the filter easy, but it’s also cheap and more environmentally friendly than constantly disposing of masks.
Earth Filter FAQ
Has Earth Filter Been Third-Party Tested?
Yes, the filter has been tested by Nelson Labs to achieve the filtration specifications mentioned here.
Does Earth Filter Fit Every Mask?
Earth Filter does not fit in every mask, however, it does fit in a large variety of masks. Smaller masks may be too small for the filter, but most larger masks will house the filter well.
What Does Earth Filter, Filter?
Earth Filter is capable of filtering viral, bacterial and fine particles. It is capable of filtering all of these to > 97% efficiency. However, the filter must be fitted correctly for this efficiency.
What Masks Can I Put Earth Filter In?
You can put Earth Filter in nearly every larger size mask on the market. Some masks with unique dimensions may not fit the filter, but the majority of standard sized masks will.